PDA

View Full Version : A request for a critique!


Ender Wiggin
13th February 2003, 15:49
Well, it's formatted properly in Word, but it doesn't seem to work on the forums. Here: http://www.writing.com/main/view_item.php?item_id=711632

That's 10 times easier to read.

If anybody has some spare time and is incredibly bored, could I interest in reading what I have of a story and crituiqing it? This is my first time writing fantasy and I have no idea whether I'm writing coherently.

At the beginning, I think it's too confusing about Merik and his wife... you can't really tell that they're married.

Well, here is is:

She walked in as he practiced the forms with the new sword he had just had forged. Dressed in only his breeches and covered with sweat, he couldn’t help but feel that her dark, always-amused eyes were studying him like a farrier would study a particularly fine horse. Despite how much he hated the piercing stare directed at him, he increased his effort, flowing seamlessly from form to form, trying to convince himself that it wasn’t because Faline was there. As she walked around the small courtyard outside of the servant’s quarters she traced her hand over the simple designs on the stone benches and fountains with that unfaltering look always on her face whenever Merik had a chance to glance at her. He knew it would happen soon. It always did. Every time he thought he had found a safe place in the palace to have a few moments to himself she would pop up as soon as he found his rhythm. Yes, there was no stopping her, she would do it in a moment.
It happened. One moment he was facing away from her thrusting at the air with his heavy one-handed sword and the next he was facing her with his sword high above his head about to smash his imaginary foe. Instead of being on the edge of the courtyard she was directly under his blade with her eyebrows raised as if to ask him whether he dared. “What is it,” he asked in the softest, nicest voice he could muster. It wasn’t very soft. Or nice.
“Now, now Meri, I was just going to inquire on whether you wanted to sup with me tonight and I didn’t want to bother the servants to come down and ask.” The smile was back and worse than ever. “I thought you might be having dinner with Tak.”
“I didn’t want to bother the servants,” he mocked. “Didn’t want to bother the servants!? That’s what they’re bloody there for. And don’t call me that,” he added with a fierce glare. It seemed to have no effect on her. If anything her smile widened.
“Watch your language, Meri. Most women I know won’t stand for that sort of talk and I think I’m beginning to agree with them. I might ask Arla if I can borrow that cane she’s always talking about. You know, the one that she uses on Dav?” Oh he had heard about the cane all right. He could not see how Dav could possibly want to do anything except what his wife ordered him, after seeing the bruises left by the cane, but Dav claimed that making up afterwards made it worth the pain. She had obviously gone insane; she hadn’t been like this when they first got married. He’d had enough. He had to get out. Tomorrow, he decided. He thought, Tomorrow, eh? Didn’t you say that yesterday and the day before? Come to think of it, you’ve been saying that for quite a while now. But it had to stop soon, before she actually decided to use that bloody cane! He wouldn’t put it past her.
“My language” he yelled, finally losing all self-control. “You curse like a stableboy with never a care for who hears you! At least I watch my bloody language around higher nobles and queens! Queens for Light’s sake! Oh don’t look so surprised; half the palace already knows what happened in there with you, the queen and the queen’s servant.” Her eyes widened before she could regain her calm.
“I will see you in our sitting room at first dark for supper with Lord Daybin and Lady Luse.” With that she spun on her heel and left though the low stone arch on the east side of the courtyard for all the world like she herself was the queen and he a servant or a queen’s pretty to be ordered around with never a question as to why.
Merik sheathed his sword in his plain leather scabbard, regretting that he wouldn’t get the chance to thank the extraordinary blacksmith that had made it for him. It had been decided. By this time tomorrow he would be gone.

***…***
After the dinner with Daybin and his wife, Merik moved his chair back from the table and sat back for a long discussion with Daybin about the succession to the crown and who was the most likely candidate.
“I’ve got my money on Saigan, but lately Faline seems to have been getting a good deal of support,” Daybin said over his goblet of spiced wine. Merik was not sure Daybin hadn’t had too much of the wine.
“Faline? Was that a joke, Daybin? I can never tell with you.” It was true; Merik could never tell whether the man was joking, lying or mourning. His facial expression hadn’t moved an inch from the first time they had met two years ago. Merik wasn’t particularly fond of Daybin, but once filled with enough wine, Daybin was a useful source of information. Until now.
Daybin looked hurt by his expression, if a slight downwards turn of the lips could be counted as an expression. “You know you can trust me, Merik; I’ve heard she’s got the support of two major houses: Nolan and one other.”
Merik looked down the long table to where his wife and Luse were quietly chattering about some women’s business that he was sure was “nothing a man had to worry about”. Faline was wearing a pained expression; she hated being in any sort of contact with Luse, but refused to stop inviting her to dinner’s and other social events. “I think it’s time you were going, Daybin. Maybe we can talk tomorrow when you’re more…” he didn’t finish his sentence. Despite the other man’s unchanging attitude towards anything and everything, Merik had come to like the man for his matter-of-factness.
Merik scraped his chair back and stood up. “It was a pleasure having you and your wife for dinner; I hope we can do it another time soon,” Merik announced loudly. Faline looked at him, her face a mask of relief. Luse appeared annoyed at being interrupted by a noble of lesser rank, but she and Faline had been friends too long for her to actually call Merik down. After two years of deferring and receiving deference he had still not gotten used to all the nuances of rank that everybody else had apparently been taught from the cradle.
As the door closed behind the two highest members of house Camber, Merik turned to his wife. “I’ll be leaving in the morning,” he said. It had to begin now. No more waiting around.
“Hunting with Tak again? I swear that you two have single-handedly reduced Andor’s deer population to half of what it was before last fall.
“No. It’s not like that. I’ll be leaving for good this time. I truly have loved you, even though you’ve infuriated me enough times to make a man mad. I need to know something before I go, though: have you been meeting with House Nolan to gain their support?” He had to know; too much hung on who got the crown.
“Merik, what in the Light are—“ she started, but was cut off by Merik.
“Tell me,” he breathed in a hardly suppressed rage. His wife looked at him in surprise; she had never seen him get like this before. Angry, yes, but this wasn’t just anger. Merik was sure he had pure fury showing on his face. Faline didn’t realize that he wasn’t in a rage because she wouldn’t tell him. He was in a rage because of what he might have to do if she gave him the wrong answer.
“Yes, yes I have met with House Nolan and House Sund, if you must know and I now have their full support,” she said in an uncertain voice that he thought was supposed to sound confident. It was the wrong answer.
He moved to embrace her. “I’m sorry,” he whispered as he hugged her. He could already feel the life draining out of her as his dagger went through her heart. As he let his wife of two years sag to the floor, tears came to his eyes. He really had loved her, but there were things more important right now than his personal feelings.
This wasn’t the time to mourn, though. His plan had finally started and there was no going back. Wiping his dagger on the new Tairen rug Faline had bought from a merchant not five days ago, he set to work. Drawing out the clothes he had first worn into Andor from the back of his wardrobe, Merik wondered at how loose these clothes had been on him when he had first entered the city. I really have gone soft; getting fat with all these nobles and their nightly feasts, he thought as he squeezed in to his plain woolen breeches. There was no time to dispose of the body, but the whole palace would know that Faline and another were dead by the next morning anyway, and it wouldn’t matter if they found out that he had done it. He would be thousands of miles away. As he belted on his sword and sheathed the rest of his knives about his body he glanced up to find a myrdraal at the doorway to his bedchamber.
“You know where this Tak sleeps?” It asked in its low rasping voice.
“Yes. His room is two levels down and directly across from the East stair’s landing. Meaning no disrespect, but we’ve been over this; Demandred himself came up with the plan,” Merik answered with as much respect as he could show to a fade. Merik looked down to check that his sword buckle was secure and when he looked back up to answer any more questions the fade had, he ended up staring at an empty doorframe. Why can’t those bloody fades announce when they’re leaving? That gives me the chills, he thought angrily.

Ender Wiggin
13th February 2003, 15:50
With one last look across the room, Merik turned to leave. As he walked down the dimly lit corridor Merik hoped the fade had not forgotten to unlock Tak’s door. Of course that was absurd; he had never heard of a halfman forgetting anything, but he still did not want to think of the consequences of leaving the palace without having completed all of his tasks. No, he could not let his mind wander now.
There wasn’t a very large chance that anybody would be out in the corridors at this time of night, but come to think of it, Luse and Daybin had only left a little while ago. There was always the chance of encountering another wine-filled noble on their way back to their carriage or room.
The walk wasn’t very long, but Merik imagined he had heard footsteps several times and had to hide until he was sure there was no one following him. Finally, he reached his good friend’s room and twisted the silver-worked oval knob. Click. The door opened. It had been silly to think that a—
Merik stopped thinking about fades when he saw what was inside of the door to Tak’s room. Two of the queen’s guards stood at the ready with their swords drawn facing Merik. Tak stood in the middle of them with his arms crossed a triumphant smile painting his face. Merik hated that arrogant look. Hated it with a passion. He had never seen Tak give him that look, but many of Merik’s opponents had given him that same look only moments before they had died. Tak thought he had Merik Chinli outnumbered, did he?
As soon as the guards saw Merik they lunged toward him. Without time to draw his sword, Merik let the knife that he had instinctively produced from his coat sleeve fly. The knife went directly into the guard’s open mouth and killed him almost instantly. Merik had no time to admire his handiwork, though. He rolled to the right just as the second guard thrust his sword. He heard the sound of a sword on wood and turned around in time to see the guard trying to pull his sword free of the door. Drawing his sword, Merik rushed towards the guard just as the sword came free. The guard fell back with nothing to support his weight and only just parried one of Merik’s attacks. With a quick glance towards Tak to make sure he posed no threat, Merik launched volley after volley of attacks at the guard. It was all the guard could do to get up and fight off the determined attacks of Merik. The guard was obviously excellent with a sword, but Merik was a blademaster; at least, he would be as soon as he went through the formal “qualification process” set up by the late queen. Merik feinted for the guard’s torso, saw that the guard had taken the bait, and sliced off the plain-faced man’s head.
Wiping his blade on the guard’s shirt, Merik looked up to see Tak stringing his bow in the corner of the sitting room.
“I always told you, you should have taken up the sword, Tak. That will do you no good, now,” said the slowly advancing Merik. Tak shot him a look of fear and hefted his bow, nervously knocking an arrow. Merik’s quick lunge cut the bow in two.
Merik growled, “How did you know I was coming? No. No, it doesn’t matter. I can trust that you were arrogant enough to think that you wouldn’t need to tell anyone about this besides your two guardsmen.” Tak’s face was agreement enough to confirm that no one had been told.
“You never did know your limits, Tak,” sneered Merik.
Tak stuttered his first words, “What…what are you going to do to me?” Merik hated to have to do this to yet another person he had truly become friends with, but Tak was too dangerous to leave alive.
Tak shuddered only once before he slid off the end of Merik’s sword into a crumpled heap.
Finally. It’s time I was off¸ thought Merik. He grabbed one of Tak’s purses off of the corpse and left the room.

***…***
That's all for now....

Master Raven
22nd April 2003, 19:32
Wow
I thought that was pretty good... especially the angle of Merik being bad, not good...
But i do have a comment or 2... the first paragraph sorta gets confusing, and it doesnt really flow very well.... that problem irons itself out in the second paragrapha nd is non existent in the rest, but in the first its very confusing
V. V. good though.... ithout it was excellent, look forward to more

Dregs
22nd April 2003, 20:02
wow thats good. Especially the combat scene. Dialogue's a little stilited (just a little, mind) but the story is brilliant.

Ender Wiggin
22nd April 2003, 21:02
Jeez, I go for a month and a half without a response and then I get two within 30 minutes. Works for me.

Thanks for the input guys, I do realize the first paragraphs are a bit... convoluted and have yet to come up with any that I like (not that I've been working to hard on it since late Feb).

What do ya mean by stilited, Dregs? Must be a literary phrase I'm not familiar with.

Thanks again, guys!

Ender Wiggin
22nd April 2003, 21:02
Jeez, I go for a month and a half without a response and then I get two within 30 minutes. Works for me.

Thanks for the input guys, I do realize the first paragraphs are a bit... convoluted and have yet to come up with any that I like (not that I've been working to hard on it since late Feb).

What do ya mean by stilited, Dregs? Must be a literary phrase I'm not familiar with.

Thanks again, guys!

Dregs
23rd April 2003, 19:07
Sorry, i just meant the dialogue didn't flow naturally, but rereeading it makes me think its just the way its spaced. I cant easily pick out the speech from the story. I often think RJ's work on dialogue needs to be improved as it doesn't go "naturally". Tolkien's dialogue, although high handed was more natural.

Other than I really like it.

(Just to be clear, i am not criticising your dialogue, just the way you have spaced it :D)

Ender Wiggin
23rd April 2003, 21:16
Oh, good. That's not really how it's spaced, though. I copied and pasted from word and didn't bother to check how the formatting came out. Apparently pretty bad; sorry for that.

Thanks!

TRUTH
1st May 2003, 14:44
hey Ender,

I like the idea behind this story. I'm not going to comment on grammar or dialogue. I know it's hard to write long things on the forum. I read it three times and each time it flowed easier for me and i liked it more. good stories come from good iedeas. changing flow is easy once you've got the idea. good stuff. :)

Ender Wiggin
27th June 2003, 20:07
Hey guys. I have it posted at Writing.com, so you can see the proper format. If any of you have time, I'd love some feedback on how it actually flows (with formatting and everything).

http://www.writing.com/main/view_item.php?item_id=711632

Dregs
30th June 2003, 21:09
Originally posted by Ender Wiggin
Hey guys. I have it posted at Writing.com, so you can see the proper format. If any of you have time, I'd love some feedback on how it actually flows (with formatting and everything).

http://www.writing.com/main/view_item.php?item_id=711632

I'm not one to hand out praise unneccisarily, but thats some good stuff, cobber. You won't be getting any book deals just yet, but its a good start. Keep writing mate.

Dregsy

Ender Wiggin
6th July 2003, 16:50
Thanks, bro. I had stopped writing this story a few motnhs ago because I wasn't sure if I actually had anything, but you guys've prompted me to continue writing (and now I realize how much I've missed writing stories whther people like them or not).

Thanks again, Dregsy...

Danae Drews
18th July 2003, 01:37
very cool so far i liked what i read